Tuesday, May 16, 2006
All-out war in The Hague (post will be updated continuously) |
|
(Also check out the anti-Verdonk T-shirts section.)
Ayaan Hirsi Ali's fellow members of the VVD free-market party are in an uproar. The normally hugely loyal Dutch VVD MP Bibi de Vries has said that 'if anything happens to AHA, her blood will be on the hands of members of my party'. Former party leader Van Aartsen appeared on television with his face looking like a freshly boiled lobster. European VVD MP's as well as Geert Dales, the VVD mayor of Leeuwarden, have condemned secretary Rita Verdonk's preliminary decision to revoke AHA's citizenship.
What will happen next?
AHA will hold a press conference, which is starting right now.
The political opposition is preparing a parliamentary condemnation of Verdonk's action. Such a condemnation will effectively end Rita Verdonk's tenure if it gets a majority.
The condemnation may very well get that majority, because of the open revolt within the VVD. Also, the right-of-centre CDA party, which supports the current administration, has expressed doubts about Verdonk.
If Verdonk has to go, then the entire Balkenende administration may have to resign, if it turns out that Balkenende was informed of Verdonk's decision.
Also, the Dutch law philosopher Afshin Ellian, a colleague of mine at Leiden University (I've never met him though), is preparing legal action against Rita Verdonk.
Stay tuned.
Press conference of AHA
13.56: Vice prime minister Gerrit Zalm openly supports AHA during her press conference, thus adding further fuel to speculations about Rita Verdonk's political future.
14.04. Zalm sneers at Verdonk, hinting at the extreme speed with which Verdonk decided to revoke AHA's citizenship: 'If she always works with this speed, the immigration service will soon be rid of all backlogs.'
Debate on Verdonk
16.45. A debate which may decide the future of Rita Verdonk is about to start. Prime minister Balkenende has distanced himself from Verdonk by expressing his reservations about the speed with which Verdonk has made her decision on AHA. This means he is probably employing a CYA strategy, intended to at least salvage the current government.
17.35. Lousewies van der Laan, who leads the centrist D66 (Democrat 66) party, has announced she will file a motion which will, if it gets a majority, effectively force secretary Rita Verdonk to use her so-called 'discretionary powers' (i.e. a sort of executive privilege) to grant AHA a new Dutch passport, before the end of this week.
17.41. Geert 'Peroxide Head' Wilders gets his turn to speak in Parliament. He says there are days when he's wondering what he's doing in politics. I've been thinking the same thing about Wilders for quite a while.
18.35. They're eating until 20.15. Take a look at our new T-shirts in the meantime ;-).
18.43. Planet Internet reports that VVD and CDA will support the D66 attempt to grant AHA Dutch citizenship after all.
21.10. Femke Halsema, leader of GroenLinks (Green Left), reveals the email address of AHA: magan@tweedekamer.nl. This means that just about everyone in The Hague must have known AHA lied about her name for years - and there's absolutely no reason why Verdonk would start an investigation into her now - apart from opportunism borne of the desire to become the leader of the VVD party.
22.15. The Second Chamber (Lower House) is in recess. You didn't miss much, as with any parliament most of decision making process does not take place in front of the cameras. VVD chief whip Willibrord van Beek spoke some ambigous but subtly ominous words to a PBS journalist about Verdonk's political future. The Second Chamber is not pleased, to say the least. And although Verdonk may still survive this debate, she's dead in the water politically. Her main competitor in the VVD leadership tussle, Mark Rutte, is sitting back while he now soars in the polls.
Of course, the guy who is laughing most is Wouter Bos, PvdA (Labour Party) leader. It was the VARA, a social-democratic PBS station (don't ask me to explain our PBS system to you, I won't), that aired the documentary that started this latest witch hunt. It is Verdonk, a person who could lead the VVD to a victory in next year's election, who had an image of being steadfast to uphold after she threw a 17 year old girl out of the country, and denied the Dutch citizenship to a talented soccer player who wanted to participate in the upcoming world championship.
Even though I am convinced Verdonk did this because out of opportunism, the reasons for it being opportune were there for all to see. If this was a trap by the PvdA, the VVD took it, hook, line and sinker. For weeks now, the VVD has been gaining seats in the polls because of the so-called 'Verdonk effect', in anticipation of her taking over the VVD leadership. I'm not optimistic about the new poll at the end of this week.
22.58. Dutch PBS reports that the VVD and CDA, the two main parties that form the government, will ask of Verdonk to reconsider her decision - or else.
23.01. Pieter Dorsman is dead wrong. I am perfectly happy being Dutch. I am just not too happy with some of my fellow countrymen and, specifically, countrywomen that are not deserving of the title.
23.10. Dutch PBS reports a compromise may be in the works between the VVD and Verdonk. Then again, this is only based on a reporter dropping in on a private little chat between Verdonk and Ter Beek, who immediately got up and left.
23.29. Van Beek (VVD) files a motion asking Verdonk to reconsider her decision. It is supported by four other parties: CDA (right-centrist), PvdA (labour), D66 (centrist liberal) and GroenLinks (way too left).
It should be added, especially for those readers who have the inclination to mask their ignorance of the local situation by throwing words such as 'cowardice' at the situation, that this course of action is not entirely without logic. CDA and VVD want to get rid of Verdonk, but they can't. It will mean elections, which the left-wing parties will win, as they are going much stronger in the polls than CDA and VVD.
This may well be the result of a compromise. It's speculation, but here's my take. The VVD leadership doesn't want Verdonk, but Mark Rutte to lead the party. So Verdonk gets to live for now - but her political career will be over after this administration resigns at the end of its term (hopefully). And she'll have to back out of the leadership race. If she announces her withdrawal from this race somewhere this week, we'll know that I was right - or not, of course, if she doesn't.
00.52. Verdonk accepts the motion, meaning she will have to either revoke her earlier revocation of AHA's citizenship, or give her a new one pronto.
01.02. But then seems to ruin it all by stubbornly interpreting the motion in exactly the way the Second Chamber doesn't intend it. This may end in her resignation after all.
01.44. A THIRD term of the debate will start at 02.00. This should not happen. It means the Second Chamber is not satisfied with the response of Verdonk to the motion it has filed. It may also mean Verdonk may still be dismissed (yes, please), and bring down the government with her (not yet, please).
01.49. Grin. Some Ayaan cartoons.
01.55. I'm signing off for the night as this may well take until morning. If you want to keep score, I suggest Google News.
9.02. It's a good thing I didn't stay up. Nothing much happened after this. But AHA will get her Dutch citizenship - one way or the other.
|
21:39 |
permalink comment(s) (11) trackback(s) (0)
|
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry
I think we'd best prepare for that left-wing Labour plus Green and/or Socialist coalition. Regardless of the exact outcome of this mini-crisis, this will definitely hurt both CDA and VVD. And I wouldn't be surprised if it hurt them sufficiently enough for the left to take over in 2007 - or sooner.
Robert John Kaper (ip:82.94.15.141) 16 May 2006 - 14:07 uur
If the government does collapse, would the general election be held early? If so, when?
I bet Verdonk never dreamed her maneuver against Hirsi Ali would backfire so badly.
vaara (ip:195.86.124.243) 16 May 2006 - 14:57 uur
Which is all the more reason why Verdonk should not hold any office, apart from one looking out at a prison yard, which is where she worked before.
We could have new elections in a matter of months.
Stay tuned. The fate of Verdonk will be decided in a debate which starts at half past four.
Arjan Dasselaar (ip:84.245.41.171) 16 May 2006 - 15:03 uur
Both Balkenende and Zalm seem to have distanced themselves from Verdonk's remarks. I'm eager to hear from Rutte though.
Robert John Kaper (ip:82.94.15.141) 16 May 2006 - 17:10 uur
Dutch politics used to be so boring...
vaara (ip:195.86.124.243) 16 May 2006 - 17:27 uur
Verdonk is just too eager to show her 'backbone'. Why the rush? The VARA is by the way an appendix of the PvdA (labour party). The plot to discredit and remove Ayaan has succeeded, alas.
Frank (ip:83.85.28.212) 16 May 2006 - 20:42 uur
Wanneer werd de politiek zo interessant in Nederland?
Regardless, I'd be happier that Hirsi Ali is coming here to the US if I knew she had a successor waiting in the wings in Den Haag.
Maitreya (ip:198.241.156.7) 16 May 2006 - 21:23 uur
Thank you so much for your work in keeping everyone abreast of this story, if you don't speak Dutch (I don't) this story would have been hard to follow if you had to rely on traditional media.
I think it is a very sad day for Holland, politics is frequently dirty and rarely honest - and that is true everywhere, but here a series of ill considered moves by a number of people have resulted in a spectatcle that is shameful. Verdonk has been monumentally stupid, and there seem to be number of people in VVD who should also be ashamed of their actions - but I do think that the poeple who set the trap that Verdonk fell into should not escape the blame, because from they certainly had no scruples about what effect their pursuit of Verdonk might have.
Johan (ip:59.154.24.146) 16 May 2006 - 3:50 uur
And by the way, people are better staying informed by reading Zacht Ei than going to google news - where the english language coverage is appalling:
The Daily Telegraph appears unaware that the immigration lies were not recently "exposed" but have been common Knowledge for some time, and more over make it seem that AHA was in tears over being caught out in her lies - astonishingly ill informed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/05/17/wmp17.xml&sSheet=/news/2006/05/17/ixnews.html
The Irish Examiner is little better, crucially failing to inform the reader that AHA had admitted the lies some years ago, and not as a result of current pressures - which puts an entirely false constrcution on the story.
Expatica, Time and Fox seem to have accurate coverage that does not leave out crucial facts.
Johan (ip:59.154.24.146) 16 May 2006 - 4:14 uur
Nederlands verlies is America's gain. Echt jammer toch!
It's a very sad day when the vindictive nature of party politics silences a voice like Ayaan's. I am an American, married to a Dutch woman, who lived in the Netherlands when Fortuyn was murdered. I didn't feel threatened by his views in any way - what he asked from immigrants was only reasonable and natural. Soon after that day we decided to leave, fortunately we had a place to go.
Does the Netherlands soon stand to loose its best and brightest? Will we soon witness an exodus similar to the Jews, with the means, who fled Hitler in his minions? Will history refer to this period as the Weimarization of the Netherlands?
And can the rest of Europe be far behind?
De Yank (ip:68.35.58.205) 16 May 2006 - 4:42 uur
I think it is utterly reprehensible that a society sacrifices its best to appease its worst. I have had my doubts about the state of affairs here in the Netherlands, but I never suspected that things would deteriorate this quickly.
It's a shame I have two more years to go here before I finish my Master's degree and can leave for the U.S. I think by the time that day comes by, there will be few things left here to miss..
Maarten (ip:86.88.18.204) 16 May 2006 - 9:49 uur
Comment
Thanks for signing in,
.
Now you can comment. (sign out)
(By submitting comments you agree to have read and accepted the forum rules. If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
|