Zacht Ei

Doorbakken kan altijd nog


Sunday, June 5, 2005

Why the 'NO' vote

Christopher Caldwell of the Weekly Standard gets it right by quoting a French teacher:

1. A constitution has to be readable to permit a popular vote; this text is unreadable.
2. A constitution doesn't impose a political ideology; this text is partisan.
3. A constitution is revisable; this text is locked in . . .
4. A constitution protects people from tyranny through separation of powers; this one doesn't have real checks and balances and separation of powers.
5. A constitution is not handed down by the powerful; it is established by the people themselves, to protect them from arbitrary power, through an independent constitutional assembly elected for the purpose and disbanded afterwards; this text entrenches European institutions designed 50 years ago by the men in power.

Exactly. Dutch PBS is tirelessly endeavouring to spin the 'NO' vote as the result of Dutch xenophobia and (just a few moments ago) our alleged fear of cheap Polish labour (which was a French concern, and by the way, my bathroom really needs new tiles. Bring 'em on).

Quite ironic it takes an American journal to get it right.

< self-indulgence mode >
Good thing there's blogs.
< /self-indulgence mode >

1:50

permalink comment(s) (2) trackback(s) (0)


« 

Behold the economical miracle of Europe   War between the Netherlands and Belgium

 »


Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry


It sounds like your mainstream press is as obsessed with race as ours. It must be easier to say "oh, it's race" when you're on deadline than to actually analyze a situation!

PJ (ip:69.166.203.224) 5 June 2005 - 2:44 uur


He's right indeed. I'm sorry to say though, that he translated (not in full) a French teacher of law, M. Étienne Chouard. The original you'll find here: http://etienne.chouard.free.fr/Europe/index.htm

Iwan (ip:83.116.176.60) 5 June 2005 - 0:24 uur


Comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(By submitting comments you agree to have read and accepted the forum rules. If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)



Remember me?